How to Escape the Commodity Trap by Positioning Your Business as Luxury - Kathryn Porritt

March 15, 2026  by Ewell Smith

In this episode of the Close The Deal Podcast, Kathryn Porritt explains why the middle market is becoming harder for businesses to compete in and why many companies must either move downmarket or reposition themselves as premium brands.  She discusses how luxury positioning works, why innovation and uniqueness drive premium pricing, and how entrepreneurs can identify what they do best in the world and build a brand around it.

Why competing on price is destroying your margins


Listen to the Close The Deal Podcast:

What You Will Learn


  • Why the middle market is collapsing for many industries
  • The difference between commodity businesses and luxury positioned brands
  • How innovation and positioning create premium pricing power
  • Why lowering prices is often the most dangerous move in uncertain markets


About the Guest


Kathryn Porritt is the founder of Iconic Empire and a luxury brand strategist who helps entrepreneurs reposition their products, services, and personal brands into luxury market offerings. She previously built one of the largest lifestyle companies in Australia before transitioning into advising entrepreneurs across North America and Europe.


The Commodity Trap Most Businesses Fall Into

When markets tighten, many business owners react the same way: they lower prices.


It feels logical. Competition increases, demand softens, and suddenly everyone is racing to the bottom. But according to luxury brand strategist Kathryn Porritt, that strategy may actually be the most dangerous move a business can make.


The middle market — where most companies operate — has become increasingly difficult to compete in. Businesses are squeezed between low-cost competitors on one side and premium brands on the other.

And the reality is simple.

You either move down… or you move up.


The Middle Market Is Getting Squeezed

For decades, many companies built their businesses by serving the middle of the market. Good product. Fair price. Solid service.

But that model is under pressure today.

Low-cost operators and global marketplaces have driven prices down. At the same time, premium brands are commanding stronger loyalty and higher margins.


The result?

The middle ground is disappearing.

Businesses that once thrived in that space now find themselves competing on price — often without realizing they’ve become commodities.


How Luxury Brands Actually Grow


Most entrepreneurs believe successful brands grow from the bottom up.

You start small. Build an audience. Increase demand. Then scale.

That’s how many large companies operate.


But luxury brands follow a completely different strategy.

They start at the top.


Instead of building scale first, they establish authority, exclusivity, and innovation at the highest level of the market. Only later do they expand into broader products and services.


Think about the fashion industry.


High-end designers begin by creating exclusive pieces for elite clients. Over time, that brand equity allows them to expand into ready-to-wear products, fragrances, and accessories.


Scale happens — but it happens downward.


Luxury Is About Innovation, Not Price

One of the biggest misconceptions about luxury is that it simply means charging more.


That’s not what drives premium demand.

Luxury customers aren’t paying for price.


They’re paying for innovation, rarity, creativity, and mastery.


They want the most advanced, the most original, or the most refined version of something.


And that applies across industries — not just fashion or luxury goods.

Even a commodity industry like seafood can transform through innovation.


The Shrimp Story That Proves the Point

During the conversation, Ewell Smith shared a powerful example from the Gulf Coast shrimp industry.


Shrimp is traditionally treated as a commodity product.

Most fishermen sell their catch for whatever the market price happens to be.


But one shrimper took a completely different approach.

Instead of competing on price, he innovated. He flash-froze shrimp immediately after catching them, preserving flavor and quality at the highest possible level.


Then he positioned the product differently.

He sold directly to top chefs and premium retailers.

Instead of selling shrimp for under a dollar per pound like the rest of the industry, his product commanded premium prices.

Same product category.


Completely different positioning.


Finding Your True Competitive Advantage

The first step toward premium positioning isn’t pricing.

It’s clarity.


Businesses must identify what they do better than anyone else in their market.


Not just what they offer. But where they are truly exceptional.

This often takes deep analysis, reflection, and research.


Once that unique advantage is clear, the next step becomes much easier: positioning that mastery to the right audience.


Selling the Vision Instead of the Pain

Traditional sales strategies often focus on pain points.

Find the problem. Agitate the problem. Sell the solution.

Luxury markets operate differently.


Yes, the need must exist. But the real driver of premium decisions is vision.

Customers invest because they see a future possibility they hadn’t previously imagined.


The role of the seller becomes helping them see that vision clearly.

When that happens, pricing becomes far less important.


The Strategic Shift Many Businesses Need

For entrepreneurs who feel trapped in price competition, the idea of moving upmarket can feel risky.


But in many cases, it’s the only path to sustainable margins.

Luxury positioning doesn’t require abandoning your expertise.

It requires redefining how the market sees it.


Because somewhere in every industry — even commodity industries — there is always a premium segment waiting for someone to lead it.


Episode Summary


In this episode of the Close The Deal Podcast, Kathryn Porritt explains why the middle market is becoming harder for businesses to compete in and why many companies must either move downmarket or reposition themselves as premium brands. She discusses how luxury positioning works, why innovation and uniqueness drive premium pricing, and how entrepreneurs can identify what they do best in the world and build a brand around it.


Key Questions This Episode Answers


  • How can entrepreneurs reposition their product or service as a luxury offering?
  • Why is the middle market becoming increasingly difficult to compete in?
  • What makes a luxury brand different from a premium priced product?
  • How do businesses escape commodity markets and improve margins?
  • What role does innovation play in luxury brand positioning?


Top Kathryn Porritt Mindset Quotes:


“The middle market has collapsed.”


“Luxury brands descend into scale.”


“You must be exceptional at what you do.”


“Innovation drives premium pricing.”


“Pricing becomes irrelevant when vision is clear.”



Frequently Asked Questions

  • How can a business reposition itself as a luxury brand?

    Businesses must identify what they do exceptionally well and differentiate through innovation, expertise, or uniqueness.

  • Why is the middle market becoming harder to compete in?

    Competition and price transparency have squeezed margins, making it difficult to maintain differentiation.


  • Does luxury positioning work for services?

    Yes. Service businesses can position themselves as premium through expertise, exclusivity, and specialized experiences

  • Is luxury positioning just about raising prices?

    No. Premium pricing must be supported by innovation and strong brand positioning.


Close The Deal Takeaway


Competing on price is rarely a winning strategy. Businesses that identify their true expertise and position it correctly can escape commodity markets and build stronger margins and better customer relationships. For more insights like this, keep learning from the Close The Deal Podcast.

If you're finding this helpful, you may enjoy 40 Top Dale Carnegie Quotes


Subscribe

Close The Deal .com Podcast on Apple Podcasts
CloseTheDeal.com podcast on Stitcher Podcasts

Laid off?


Not valued?


Ready to exit?


Discovered ageism

 is real? 


Be The Boss.


Book cover:

Close The Deal on

Your First Franchise

Claim Your Free Copy

Ewell Smith, host of the Close The Deal Podcast, discussing sales systems and revenue growth

About the Author Ewell Smith is the publisher of CloseTheDeal.com, host of the Close The Deal Podcast, and author of Your First Franchise Roadmap. He interviews franchisors, founders, and sales and marketing leaders to help franchise owners and candidates drive more revenue and find the right opportunity. His work focuses on practical franchise strategy, the right mindset, and helping people close the deal on their next chapter.

Person pausing before taking a step, illustrating fear and procrastination in decision making
By ewell smith April 17, 2026
The number one thing I see that kills more deals than anything else isn’t money, timing, or even opportunity. It’s fear. As a franchise consultant, I see it play out every single day. Someone gets close to making a decision. They like the brand, they understand the model, and they can clearly see the path forward. Then something shifts. Doubt creeps in. Questions start stacking up. They begin to wonder if they can really do it, if they’re capable of running the business, or if they’re taking on more risk than they should. From there, hesitation sets in. That hesitation slows momentum, and what started as a strong, forward-moving decision turns into delay. That delay eventually becomes procrastination. And more often than not, that procrastination leads to inaction. The deal never gets done. What’s interesting is that fear rarely shows up as something obvious. It doesn’t announce itself. Instead, it disguises itself as logic. It sounds like someone wanting more time, more information, or more certainty. It shows up as overthinking or the desire to get everything just right before making a move. One of the most common forms of this is perfectionism. People convince themselves they’re being careful or strategic, when in reality they’re avoiding taking action because they don’t want to get it wrong. The truth is, there is no perfect time. There never has been, and there never will be. Waiting for perfect conditions is one of the easiest ways to stay stuck without realizing it. That’s why, once you’ve made a decision that matters, it’s critical to keep moving. Not all at once, and not in a perfect way, but through small, consistent steps that build momentum. That’s what separates people who move forward from those who stay stuck in place. This is also a core theme behind the Close The Deal Podcast. Even high performers, people who are successful in many areas of their lives, still struggle with procrastination. They still find ways to delay decisions or avoid uncomfortable actions. Sometimes the reasons sound legitimate, but more often they’re just well-disguised excuses rooted in fear. The quotes below resonate because they cut through that noise. They don’t just sound good, they point directly at what’s really going on beneath the surface. Let them challenge the way you’re thinking about the thing you’ve been putting off. And when you’re ready to move, there’s a short guide on this page that walks you through simple steps to take immediate action and get started. 11 Quotes That Expose Fear (and Push You to Act) “Procrastination is not a time management problem. It’s an emotion management problem.” - Timothy Pychyl 2. “Do one thing every day that scares you.” - Eleanor Roosevelt 3. “Inaction breeds doubt and fear. Action breeds confidence and courage.” - Dale Carnegie 4.“Fear defeats more people than any other one thing in the world.” - Ralph Waldo Emerson 5. “Action cures fear.” - David J Schwartz 6. “Do the thing you fear, and the death of fear is certain.” - Ralph Waldo Emerson 7. “Everything you’ve ever wanted is on the other side of fear.” - George Addair 8. “Fear is only as deep as the mind allows.” - Japanese proverb 9. “Courage is resistance to fear, mastery of fear—not absence of fear.” - Mark Twain 10. “If you are not willing to risk the usual, you will have to settle for the ordinary.” - Jim Rohn 11. “Do what you can, with what you have, where you are.” - Theodore Roosevelt Close The Deal With Yourself If something came to mind while reading this, that’s probably the thing you’ve been putting off. Not everything, just one decision or action that’s been sitting there longer than it should. You don’t need to solve the whole thing today. Just take the first step. That might be making a call, sending an email, or simply starting the process. Momentum doesn’t come from thinking about it, it comes from doing something, even if it’s small. If you want help getting started, there’s a short guide on this page that breaks down simple steps to take immediate action. It’s designed to help you move past hesitation and actually begin. Because at the end of the day, the goal isn’t to think about it. The goal is to start. FAQ (Fear, Procrastination, and Taking Action)
om Cox explaining why business owners struggle with cash flow and financial control
By ewell smith March 24, 2026
Most business owners don’t have a revenue problem—they have a cash flow problem. Learn how to fix it and take control of your money.
Stand Strong Fencing residential fence installation
By ewell smith March 18, 2026
Stand Strong Fencing Franchise excels in the high demand home services fencing market. They are backed by a powerhouse franchise group that provides superb support.